More Expensive than Manhattan: Land Reform in PNG



Papua New Guinea is becoming increasingly divided by long-standing tensions relating to the campaign for land reform, alongside soaring rates of land-related violence. Many within the government, development, private, and extractive sectors are strongly advocating for further changes to PNG’s property law system. However, with millions of hectares being signed away for 99-year leases (as well as increasing protests against mining ventures) communities in PNG are pushing back against attempts to erode their customary title.

PNG has one of the most unusual land law systems in the world. Upon attaining independence in 1975, virtually all land in PNG was placed under customary ownership – a system in which indigenous communities have claim to their land. It is estimated that some 97% of land in Papua New Guinea remains customary land. These figures are relatively unique to Melanesia, with Vanuatu holding approximately 98% of its land under customary title, and Fiji holding 90%.

Supporters of land reform argue that significant alterations are needed in order to spur growth, attract investors, and to facilitate commercial projects. It is extremely difficult to negotiate sales of customary land in PNG, since an exchange can only be conducted once a collective agreement between all members of the applicable clan has been achieved. Even if this is achieved, potential buyers must battle a complex and lengthy set of procedural barriers in order to register property, a process which is perpetually subject to the possibility that an excluded clan member may decide to retract the sale.

As such, the value of the tiny amount of alienated land that exists in PNG has skyrocketed. Property prices for non-customary land are exorbitantly high in PNG, with house prices currently hovering around AUD $670,000. Office floor rentals and accommodation in Port Moresby are reportedly more expensive than their equivalents in Manhattan, with an average apartment going for a cool $1300 per week. Many locals find themselves homeless in the city centre, with rental prices hopelessly out of reach for persons earning the AUD $60 minimum wage per week. Slum settlements continue to boom on the outskirts of the city. However, it is alleged that many of these squatters became the target of a police crackdown in November 2015 since, once cleared, this ‘valuable land’ could be auctioned off to the highest-bidding developers.

In a country that has failed to meet any of the Millennium Development Goals, and one with an ailing economy desperate to attract foreign liquidity, the need to address the customary title ‘problem’ has become a major priority for the O’Neill administration. Substantial amendments were made in 2012 to the Land Groups Incorporation Act 1974 and the Land Registration Act 1981. These amendments formed part of the government’s bold new National Land Development Program (NDLP), which brought with it a rash of legislative changes to facilitate the registration and commercial use of customary land.

Some 5,114,912 hectares have been leased under the new government-issued Special Agricultural and Business Leases (SABLs). Since 1995, 12% of the country’s land has been leased under the SABLs. A recent Commission of Inquiry into the SABL system revealed widespread corruption and irregularities, with the 2013 report revealing that out of 42 leases, only 4 had received landowner consent, whilst the other 38 were "seriously compromised". Although the NDLP’s changes have been branded by some as rash and intemperate, many resent the slow pace of the reform program, which is gradually being phased in from 2011-2030.

Meanwhile, adherents of the customary title system point out that customary tenure remains the backbone and a source of livelihood for more than 85% of PNG’s rural population. Attachment to land and custom runs deep in PNG, with many indigenous landowners believing that eroding customary tenure for the sake of enhancing rural economic integration is "the antithesis of development". AidWatch reports that the reform movement is widely interpreted as an externally imposed policy, arguing that “[t]he way in which customary land doesn’t “work” is for foreign investors, including mining companies, the forest industry, and cash crop farming industries, which find it difficult to negotiate consent to exploit the land.”

Whilst its proponents argue that land reform is key to unlocking PNG’s development potential, and providing affordable housing, many remain sceptical that it is being used as a tool to remove procedural barriers to exploit customary land for commercial purposes. Land disputes remain the main source of violence in many of the provinces, and the spectre of the bloody Bougainville crisis looms large over the national imagination. Meanwhile, commercial enterprise and squatters alike in PNG seem doomed to struggle for possession of the same 30,000 hectares of alienated land, and the O’Neill government is left with a serious problem on its hands. As a senior PNG Law and Justice staffer remarked, “land use and land mediation will make or break this country”.

Sally Andrews is the Indo Pacific Fellow at Young Australians in International Affairs.

This article can be republished with attribution under a Creative Commons Licence. Please email publications@youngausint.org.au for more information.

Image credit: The Commonwealth (cropped and filter added) (Flickr: Creative Commons)

#Insights

CAREER RESOURCES

  • Facebook - White Circle
  • Twitter - White Circle
  • LinkedIn - White Circle

© 2020 Young Australians in International Affairs, Incorporated.

ABN: 35 134 986 228 ARBN: 609 452 333

Website Design www.olyablack.com