top of page

Did the Middle East just form its own NATO?

3 minutes ago
5 min read

Anne Jacob | Middle East Fellow


Image sourced from President.Az via Wikimedia Commons


On 7 August 2026, Saudi Arabia, Türkiye, and Pakistan signed the Mecca Defence Alliance (the “Mecca Pact”), a trilateral pact that commentators quickly labelled a “Muslim NATO”. The agreement extends a September 2025 Saudi-Pakistan mutual defence deal to include Türkiye – together the three form a sizeable military bloc, with nearly 1.4 million active personnel, 3,400 aircraft, 6,000 tanks, and 340 naval assets. With Saudi Arabia as a leading global oil exporter, Türkiye holding NATO’s second largest military, and a nuclear-armed Pakistan, this may be the most significant geopolitical development shaping the region.

 

While the full text has not been made public, it does declare that an armed attack on any one of the three will be regarded as an attack on all, reminiscent of NATO’s Article 5 provision. Within roughly 48 hours of signing the agreement, Houthi forces struck an Aramco refinery in Jazan – but Saudi Arabia did not call on its new partners until two months later, and even then the response was one of support rather than retaliation. So, really, what is this pact?

 

Is It a Middle Eastern NATO?

 

Not in any structural sense. NATO was built around a common threat; the Mecca Pact, on the other hand, names no specific adversary. The “attack on all” clause ostensibly obliges members to defend one another, but there is no defined trigger or arrangement for doing so.

 

Analysts describe the agreement as “strategic hedging rather than a meaningful military pact”, and the vagueness looks deliberate. To limit the risk of being dragged into one another’s wars, the three states have kept operational execution undefined and omitted any automatic military response. The pact is perhaps better read as an attempt at collective deterrence that avoids drawing a new geopolitical dividing line and shows that middle powers are becoming reluctant to outsource their security to the greater ones.

 

That leaves a practical question: what counts as an attack? A Houthi drone strike on an oil facility? A militia strike on a power station? As far as anyone outside the three governments knows, the text does not say.

 

The First Test

 

The Houthi front is the closest thing the pact has had to a trial. After the Jazan strike, Pakistan stated on 10 September that it was not considering an immediate military response, and both Türkiye and Pakistan confirmed the Saudi government had not asked for help. The pact produced words of support, but not any visible military action. 

 

This changed in early October, when Türkiye and Pakistan rapidly deployed forces to the Kingdom in a bid to activate collective deterrence measures. Importantly, these forces were not sent to be combative, but to play a supportive role: a defensive shield.

 

Where the US Fits In

 

The timing matters. In September, the United States completed its withdrawal from Iraq, ending a 12-year coalition mission. US air defences that helped intercept Iranian missiles and drones over Erbil went with it. Iraqi Kurdistan says it has faced more than 1,000 drone and missile attacks since February, and Iraq has pushed the deadline for militias to disarm to June 2027 following resistance from dominant groups.

 

The erosion of US security assurances has made Middle Eastern states realise the need to take greater responsibility for their own security structures. In particular, Israel’s September 2025 attack on Qatar raised questions of the reliability of US security commitments to its Gulf allies. This has only been exacerbated by the increasingly protracted Iran-US war.

 

It is tempting to see the Mecca Pact as a replacement, with arguments that the US-led regional order is over. But maybe, this is diversification without substitution instead. There is no sign that Riyadh is unwinding its US ties or abandoning its goal of a formal US defence treaty. Great powers still matter, middle powers are just less willing to rely on them alone.

 

Why It’s Symbolic, and What to Watch

 

Today the pact’s value is largely political. It signals increasing strategic autonomy in security. From an economic lens, it opens Saudi financial markets to Turkish and Pakistani defence firms and gives Saudi Arabia leverage in its dealings with the US.

 

In terms of expansion, Türkiye expects Egypt to be the next state to join. Saudi Arabia’s decision to pursue new regional security alliances has caused tensions with the Gulf Cooperation Council (GCC), particularly the United Arab Emirates. Despite this, former Qatari Prime Minister Sheikh Hamad bin Jassim Al Thani expressed hope that all GCC members would take the initiative to join the Pact, with Qatar and Kuwait identified as likely to join given their need for protection following Iran and Israeli strikes on their states last year.

 

China is a quiet but awkward beneficiary. Pakistan already operates Chinese-supplied air defences in Saudi Arabia, yet Turkish arms compete with Chinese exports. The pact also links Gulf security to South Asia. The Indian Government has stated that it is examining its implications; Pakistan could in theory seek backing from pact partners in a future crisis against India, however Indian officials doubt Saudi Arabia or Türkiye would fight for Pakistan in such a conflict.

 

Ultimately, the first test answers what the text does not. The pact is a way of adding partners to each other’s defence arrangements without committing to fight in each other’s wars. Until a partner is asked to do more than simply defend, the true extent of what the pact seeks to establish for Middle Eastern security is yet to be seen but is nonetheless a promising step toward cohesion in the region.

 

Anne Jacob is an Australian-qualified lawyer with experience in complex commercial litigation, international arbitration and regulatory matters across the energy, oil and gas, and financial crime sectors. She spent six months working in the Middle East where she developed a keen interest in the region’s rapid economic and infrastructure transformation, its growing influence in global energy markets, and the legal and policy challenges arising from labour migration.

​

Her principal areas of interest are public international law, human rights and international dispute resolution, and currently volunteers with legal counsel at Amnesty International Australia. Through this fellowship, Anne hopes to explore Australia’s engagement with the Middle East and make complex legal and policy issues accessible to broader audiences.

 

Disclaimer: The views and opinions expressed in this article are those of the author, and do not necessarily reflect the views and opinions of Young Australians in International Affairs. AI tools were used by this author for grammar checks and idea refinement, but all content is original, and no plagiarism has been used in the preparation of this article.

 
 
 

Comments


  • Instagram
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn
acnc-registered-charity-logo_rgb.png

Young Australians in International Affairs is a registered charity with the Australian Charities and Not-for-Profits Commission.

YAIA would like to acknowledge Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples as Australia’s First People and Traditional Custodians.​

 

We value their cultures, identities, and continuing connection to country, waters, kin and community.

 

We pay our respects to Elders, both past and present, and are committed to supporting the next generation of young Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander leaders.

© 2025 Young Australians in International Affairs Ltd

ABN 35 134 986 228
ACN 632 626 110

bottom of page